Among these cigar ashtrays, the GUEVARA Large Porcelain Cigar Ashtray is my best overall pick for a simple, substantial everyday option, while the BESUPERT walnut model stands out for its four rests and built-in cutter. For outdoor use, the lidded extra-large ashtray offers a different advantage: it helps contain ash between cleanups. The main choice is whether you value easy washing, weather-friendly materials, multiple cigar rests, or a polished look for a lounge or patio. A larger tray can be less convenient to store, and wood or metal designs may need different care than ceramic or silicone. Read on for the full breakdown and help matching a design to your space and habits.
Get home appliances delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The GUEVARA Large Porcelain Cigar Ashtray is the strongest all-around choice for buyers who want a straightforward ceramic tray without a built-in accessory set.
- BESUPERT’s walnut design combines four cigar rests with a cutter, making it the most accessory-focused pick, though its wood finish calls for more care than silicone.
- Silicone models lead on portability and forgiving cleanup: Roygra’s two-pack suits buyers who want more than one tray, while USEAMIE adds four rests in a single flexible design.
- Lids separate the outdoor-minded options from open trays by helping contain ash between cleanups, but they add a part to handle and store.
- Material and footprint matter as much as rest count: ceramic offers a substantial, easy-wipe surface, while metal, wood, and silicone each bring different maintenance and placement tradeoffs.
| cigar ashtray | Shape | Material | Color | Dimensions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GUEVARA Large Porcelain Cigar | Round | Porcelain | Beige | 7.3 × 7.3 × 2.8 in |
| Square Wooden Cigar Ashtray wi | Square | Wood | Brown | — |
| Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtrays | Square | Silicone | Black | 4.92 × 4.92 × 1.5 in each |
| GUEVARA 8-Inch Round Outdoor C | Round | Ceramic | Yellow | — |
| USEAMIE Large Silicone Cigar A | Square | Silicone | Black | 6 × 6 × 1.5 in |
| BESUPERT Premium Walnut Wood C | Square | Walnut wood | Brown | 5.5 × 5.1 × 1.8 inches |
| Seliau Large Black Ceramic Cig | Square | Ceramic | Black | 7.6 × 7.6 × 1.1 inches |
| Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtray | Square | Silicone | Black | 4.92 × 4.92 × 1.5 inches |
| OILP Square Metal Cigar Ashtra | Square | Metal and PC | — | Approximately 6.1 × 6.1 × 1.58 inches |
| Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtray | Square | Silicone | Black | 5.9 × 5.9 × 1.5 inches |
| Extra-Large Outdoor and Indoor | Round | Metal | Bronze | 7 x 7 x 4 in |
| OILP Cigar Ashtray with Solid | Square | — | Black | 5.91 x 5.91 x 1.42 in (listed) |
| Roygra Metal Cigar Ashtray wit | Taper | Metal | Bronze | 4.5 x 3.7 x 4.5 in |
| Roygra Ceramic Cigar Ashtray | Oval | Ceramic | Black | 4.8 x 2.8 x 1 in |
More Details on Our Top Picks
GUEVARA Large Porcelain Cigar Ashtray
The GUEVARA Large Porcelain Cigar Ashtray suits a table where several people want a place to rest a cigar at once. Its four rests and deep basin give it more shared-use capacity than the single-holder Roygra Ceramic Cigar Ashtray, while the 2.5-pound porcelain body is less likely to shift around on a table than a lightweight silicone option. The tradeoff is footprint: at 7.3 inches across, it takes up more room than the compact USEAMIE Large Silicone Cigar Ashtray. Porcelain is also rigid and can break if dropped, so it calls for more care than flexible silicone on a busy patio. I’d choose it for a stable indoor or outdoor setup where easy wipe-downs and space for multiple cigars matter more than drop resistance.
Pros:- Four rests let multiple cigar smokers share the ashtray
- Deep basin holds ash between cleanings
- 2.5-pound porcelain construction provides a substantial tabletop feel
- Porcelain surface is easy to wipe clean
Cons:- 7.3-inch diameter takes considerable table space
- Rigid porcelain can crack or break if dropped
Best for: Hosts who want four cigar rests and a deep, easy-clean basin on a roomy patio or lounge table
Not ideal for: Small-table owners or anyone who wants a drop-resistant ashtray, since its large porcelain body takes space and can break if dropped
- Material:Porcelain
- Shape:Round
- Dimensions:7.3 × 7.3 × 2.8 in
- Weight:2.5 lb
- Cigar rests:4
- Color:Beige
- Use:Indoor and outdoor
- Unit count:1
Our verdict“Choose this porcelain model for a spacious shared table where capacity and a deep basin matter more than drop resistance.”
Square Wooden Cigar Ashtray with Stainless Steel Liner, Brown
The Square Wooden Cigar Ashtray is the style-led choice here: its brown wood exterior brings a warmer look than the yellow GUEVARA 8-Inch Round Outdoor Ceramic Cigar Ashtray, and the stainless steel liner gives ash and cleaning a separate, washable surface. Four rests make it practical for a small group, while the non-slip base is intended to help protect the table beneath it. Its 360-gram weight is lighter than the porcelain GUEVARA Large Porcelain Cigar Ashtray, which may make it easier to move but gives it less heft. A key limitation is that the listed dimensions of 1 × 1 × 1 inch appear unreliable, so buyers cannot confidently judge its footprint from the supplied specs. I’d pick it for a wood-accented indoor space, with that sizing uncertainty in mind.
Pros:- Stainless steel liner provides a washable surface for ash
- Four rests accommodate several cigars or cigarettes
- Non-slip base is designed to help protect the supporting surface
- Wood exterior offers a warmer look than ceramic or silicone picks
Cons:- Listed dimensions of 1 × 1 × 1 inch appear unreliable
- At 360 g, it has less heft than the porcelain GUEVARA model
Best for: Cigar smokers furnishing a wood-accented lounge who want four rests and a removable-feeling metal cleaning surface
Not ideal for: Buyers who need dependable size information or a heavy, fixed-feeling ashtray, since the listed dimensions appear inaccurate and the item weighs 360 g
- Brand:MDCGFOD
- Material:Wood
- Liner:Stainless steel
- Color:Brown
- Shape:Square
- Capacity:4 rests
- Item weight:360 g
- Included:Gift box
Our verdict“Pick this wood-and-steel design for a coordinated lounge look if you can confirm its size before buying.”
Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtrays, 2 Pack, Black
The Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtrays 2 Pack is the clearest choice for someone who wants an ashtray at two spots without moving one back and forth. Each square tray has four rests and measures just under five inches across, making the pair easier to place on smaller side tables than the 7.87-inch GUEVARA 8-Inch Round Outdoor Ceramic Cigar Ashtray. Silicone also bends instead of shattering, and the listing describes the trays as suited to wind, rain, and sun, with a rinse-clean surface. The tradeoff is a softer, less formal feel than the ceramic or porcelain picks, and the per-tray size offers less room than the larger USEAMIE silicone model. I’d choose this set for flexible outdoor use or multiple seating areas, rather than for a rigid centerpiece.
Pros:- Two ashtrays cover separate seating spots
- Four rests on each tray provide space for multiple cigars
- Flexible silicone resists breakage from ordinary drops
- Designed for outdoor exposure and rinses clean with water
Cons:- Soft silicone may feel less substantial than ceramic or porcelain
- Each tray is smaller than the USEAMIE Large Silicone Cigar Ashtray
Best for: People who want a compact ashtray at two seating areas, such as a patio table and an indoor cigar corner
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer a rigid, substantial centerpiece or need the largest bowl available
- Brand:Roygra
- Material:Silicone
- Color:Black
- Quantity:2 ashtrays
- Dimensions:4.92 × 4.92 × 1.5 in each
- Cigar rests:4 per ashtray
- Weight:0.45 kg
- Shape:Square
- Recommended use:Indoor and outdoor
Our verdict“Choose this pair when two compact, weather-ready ashtrays are more useful than one large rigid tray.”
GUEVARA 8-Inch Round Outdoor Ceramic Cigar Ashtray
The GUEVARA 8-Inch Round Outdoor Ceramic Cigar Ashtray is the broad, weighty ceramic pick for a patio table. Its 7.87-inch diameter, four rests, and deep basin give cigars room to sit securely and leave ash space for shared use; the resting lip is described as wind-resistant. Compared with the GUEVARA Large Porcelain Cigar Ashtray, it is slightly wider but lighter at 1.98 pounds, a useful balance for moving between indoor and outdoor tables. The cost of that rigid ceramic build is fragility: the product information notes that it may arrive cracked or broken, and ceramic can be damaged by a hard drop. I’d favor it over the Roygra two-pack when a larger single tray and a more substantial tabletop presence matter more than portability or impact resistance.
Pros:- Wide 7.87-inch diameter provides a roomy shared surface
- Four rests support multiple cigars
- Deep basin and wind-resistant resting lip suit outdoor use
- At 1.98 lb, it is lighter than the GUEVARA porcelain model
Cons:- Ceramic can crack or break from impact
- Product information notes a risk of arriving cracked or broken
Best for: Patio hosts who want one broad ceramic ashtray with four rests and a deep shared basin
Not ideal for: People who need a break-resistant tray or frequently carry an ashtray between locations, since ceramic is fragile and may arrive damaged
- Material:Ceramic
- Shape:Round
- Diameter:7.87 in
- Height:2.48 in
- Weight:1.98 lb
- Cigar rests:4
- Use:Indoor and outdoor
- Color:Yellow
Our verdict“Choose this ceramic model for a roomy patio centerpiece if you are comfortable handling a fragile ashtray.”
USEAMIE Large Silicone Cigar Ashtray with 4 Rests
The USEAMIE Large Silicone Cigar Ashtray is the practical pick for smokers whose cigars need a wider resting point: its four broad rests are listed to fit cigars up to 60+ ring gauge. The 6-inch square tray is larger than each Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtray in the two-pack, so it gives one table a roomier landing place without taking up as much space as the 7.87-inch GUEVARA ceramic model. Its soft, weatherproof silicone is designed to avoid scratches and breakage if dropped, and the coated surface rinses clean. The tradeoff is a lightweight, flexible feel rather than the stable, rigid presence of porcelain or ceramic. Only black is listed, and no removable parts are specified. I’d pick it for everyday cigar use where fit and easy cleanup outrank a formal finish.
Pros:- Four wide rests are listed to fit cigars up to 60+ ring gauge
- Soft silicone is designed to resist breakage and protect surfaces from scratches
- Weatherproof construction supports indoor and outdoor use
- Coated surface rinses clean with water or soapy water
Cons:- Lightweight silicone feels less substantial than the GUEVARA ceramic and porcelain models
- Only black is listed
- No removable parts are specified
Best for: Smokers who regularly use large-ring-gauge cigars and want a weatherproof, easy-clean ashtray
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a heavy, rigid centerpiece or a choice of colors
- Brand:USEAMIE
- Material:Silicone
- Dimensions:6 × 6 × 1.5 in
- Weight:0.15 kg
- Color:Black
- Shape:Square
- Cigar rests:4
- Use:Indoor and outdoor
- Special features:Weatherproof, unbreakable, large center bowl
Our verdict“Choose this model if wide rests for large cigars and easy outdoor cleanup matter more than a rigid finish.”
BESUPERT Premium Walnut Wood Cigar Ashtray with Cutter and 4-Slot Holder
The BESUPERT walnut ashtray suits a host who wants cigar rests and a cutter gathered in one tabletop piece. Its four slots give guests room to set down cigars, while the included cutter keeps a basic accessory close at hand. Compared with the OILP Square Metal Cigar Ashtray, BESUPERT trades a rigid metal build for a warmer wood finish and a bundled cutter. The heat-resistant varnish is intended to protect the surface, but wood still calls for more careful upkeep than ceramic or silicone, especially around ash and moisture. Its roughly 5.5-inch footprint is also smaller than the Seliau ceramic model, so it makes more sense for a compact gathering than a crowded table with several large cigars.
Pros:- Four slots accommodate several cigars or cigarettes
- Included cutter keeps a useful accessory nearby
- Walnut grain gives each piece a distinct appearance
- Heat-resistant varnish is specified to protect the wood finish
Cons:- Wood needs more care than ceramic or silicone around ash and moisture
- Compact footprint may feel crowded with larger cigars or several users
- Square shape may not sit neatly on every round table
Best for: Hosts who want a compact, decorative ashtray with four cigar rests and a cutter ready for guests.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a low-care ashtray for frequent outdoor use or a large surface for group smoking.
- Brand:BESUPERT
- Material:Walnut wood
- Dimensions:5.5 × 5.1 × 1.8 inches
- Weight:10.56 ounces
- Shape:Square
- Capacity:4 slots
- Included accessory:Cigar cutter
- Color:Brown
Our verdict“Choose BESUPERT for a small gathering where walnut styling and an included cutter matter more than carefree cleanup.”
Seliau Large Black Ceramic Cigar Ashtray
The Seliau ceramic ashtray is the straightforward choice for buyers who value a broad, easy-to-clean surface over bundled accessories. At 7.6 inches square, it offers more room than the compact BESUPERT walnut ashtray, making it better suited to a shared table. Its ceramic body and four bottom pads give it a stable, surface-conscious setup for indoor or outdoor use, though the listing also flags possible breakage on arrival. That fragility is the main tradeoff against the Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtray, which is flexible and described as unbreakable but has a smaller footprint. Seliau keeps the design simple: there is no cutter or elaborate accessory set, just a larger ceramic basin that should be easy to wipe clean.
Pros:- 7.6-inch square surface provides room for shared use
- Ceramic construction is easy to clean
- Four bottom pads help protect the table beneath it
- Suitable for indoor and outdoor use
Cons:- Ceramic can crack or break, and the listing notes arrival damage as a possibility
- Larger footprint takes up more table space than compact options
- No cutter or other accessories are included
Best for: Cigar smokers who want a roomy, simple ceramic ashtray for a patio table or shared indoor space.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a drop-resistant ashtray, a compact travel option, or included cigar accessories.
- Brand:Seliau
- Material:Ceramic
- Color:Black
- Shape:Square
- Dimensions:7.6 × 7.6 × 1.1 inches
- Bottom protection:4 protective pads
- Included components:1 ashtray
- Intended use:Indoor and outdoor
Our verdict“Pick Seliau for a roomy ceramic ashtray and easy cleanup if you can accommodate its size and handle it carefully.”
Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtray, 4-Holder
For a small patio table, the Roygra four-holder silicone ashtray keeps the setup light and uncomplicated. Its 4.92-inch square body takes up less room than the larger Seliau ceramic ashtray, while four rests still give a small group places to set down cigars. The flexible construction is designed to resist breakage and rinse clean, a practical advantage over ceramic if the ashtray might be moved around or used outdoors. That flexibility is also its clearest compromise: it lacks the firm, substantial feel of the OILP metal ashtray, and silicone may not suit buyers who want a rigid, weighty piece. The gift box and brand card add presentation, but the listing does not include cutters or other smoking accessories.
Pros:- Compact 4.92-inch square footprint
- Flexible construction is described as unbreakable
- Four rests provide places for multiple cigars
- Easy to rinse clean and suitable for indoor or outdoor use
Cons:- Flexible silicone may feel less substantial than metal or ceramic
- No cutter is included
- Small surface may be less comfortable for a larger group
Best for: Smokers with limited table space who want a lightweight, rinse-clean ashtray for indoor or outdoor use.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer a rigid ashtray with a more substantial feel or want cutters included.
- Brand:Roygra
- Material:Silicone
- Color:Black
- Shape:Square
- Dimensions:4.92 × 4.92 × 1.5 inches
- Cigar rests:4
- Included:Ashtray and brand card in gift box
- Model number:SiliconeAshtray-L-BK
Our verdict“Choose this Roygra if compact size and break-resistant flexibility matter more than a rigid feel or included accessories.”
OILP Square Metal Cigar Ashtray for Indoor and Outdoor Use
The OILP square metal ashtray is the rigid, weighty option in this group: at 1.2 pounds, it is less likely to feel flimsy on a patio table than the small Roygra silicone ashtray. Four rests accommodate cigars or cigarettes, and the approximately 6.1-inch square size gives it a middle ground between that compact silicone pick and the larger Seliau ceramic ashtray. The metal and PC construction is listed as easy to clean and suitable for indoor or outdoor use. One caveat is the product copy’s conflicting finish descriptions; it lists yellow as the color while describing a polished metal finish, so buyers who care about a particular look may find the listing unclear. It includes no cutter or other accessories.
Pros:- Four rests hold cigars or cigarettes
- Listed weight of 1.2 pounds gives it a sturdy feel
- Suitable for indoor and outdoor use
- Easy-to-clean construction
Cons:- Product text conflicts between a yellow color and polished metal finish
- Heavier than the silicone options in this group
- No cutter or accessories are included
Best for: Buyers who want a heavier, rigid four-rest ashtray that can move between indoor and outdoor tables.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who need reliable finish details or prefer a light, flexible ashtray that is easy to pack away.
- Brand:OILP
- Material:Metal and PC
- Shape:Square
- Color listed:Yellow
- Dimensions:Approximately 6.1 × 6.1 × 1.58 inches
- Weight:1.2 pounds
- Cigar rests:4
- Intended use:Indoor and outdoor
Our verdict“Choose OILP for a substantial, rigid ashtray with four rests if the unclear finish description does not concern you.”
Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtray Set with Three Cutters
The Roygra silicone set is aimed at outdoor smokers who want an ashtray and several cutting styles together. Along with four rests, it includes a guillotine cutter, V-cut cutter, and cigar punch, giving it a more complete accessory bundle than the walnut BESUPERT, which includes one cutter. Its 5.9-inch square ashtray is larger than the compact Roygra four-holder silicone ashtray, and the flexible body is described as weather resistant and easy to clean. The compromise is the same soft construction: buyers looking for a firm, decorative tabletop piece may prefer the OILP metal ashtray or Seliau ceramic. The listing’s broad compatibility claim does not change the modest surface area, so this set fits casual outdoor use better than a crowded gathering.
Pros:- Includes guillotine, V-cut, and punch cutters
- Four rests provide places to set down several cigars
- Flexible silicone is described as unbreakable
- Easy to clean and designed for outdoor use
Cons:- Soft silicone may not appeal to buyers who want a rigid ashtray
- 5.9-inch footprint may feel limited for a larger gathering
- Cutters use stainless steel and plastic, rather than an all-metal construction
Best for: Outdoor cigar smokers who want one compact set with multiple cutter styles and a flexible ashtray.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer a rigid ashtray, need a larger shared surface, or already own suitable cutters.
- Brand:Roygra
- Material:Silicone
- Color:Black
- Shape:Square
- Dimensions:5.9 × 5.9 × 1.5 inches
- Cigar rests:4
- Included cutters:Guillotine cutter, V-cut cutter, and cigar punch
- Cutter materials:Stainless steel and plastic
- Intended use:Outdoor
Our verdict“Pick this set for outdoor convenience and three cutter styles, provided a flexible ashtray suits your table setup.”
Extra-Large Outdoor and Indoor Cigar Ashtray with Lid
The Extra-Large Outdoor and Indoor Cigar Ashtray with Lid is the strongest fit here for a patio where loose ash, rain, or odors are a concern. Its lid and deep bowl help contain debris between uses, while four wide rests give a small group room to set down cigars. Compared with the compact, single-cigar Roygra Ceramic Cigar Ashtray, this OILP has more capacity and shared-use flexibility; the ceramic pick is easier to tuck away and carry. The bronze metal body can be rinsed clean, which keeps routine cleanup simple, but the listing gives no specific weather-resistance or durability details. Its 7-inch footprint also takes more table space than a personal ashtray, so it suits a patio station better than a crowded side table.
Pros:- Lid helps limit rain, windblown ash, and lingering odors
- Four wide rests serve several cigar smokers
- Deep bowl provides room for ash between cleanings
- Metal body can be rinsed clean
Cons:- No specific weather-resistance or long-term durability details are provided
- Its 7-inch width takes more space than compact personal models
Best for: Patio hosts who want a lidded ashtray with room for several cigar smokers
Not ideal for: Solo smokers with limited table space who want a lightweight, compact ashtray
- Brand:OILP
- Material:Metal
- Color:Bronze
- Shape:Round
- Dimensions:7 x 7 x 4 in
- Weight:1.4 lb
- Cigar rests:4
- Use:Indoor and outdoor
- Special features:Lid, windproof design, large capacity
Our verdict“Choose this OILP for a shared patio setup where a lid and generous capacity matter more than compact storage.”
OILP Cigar Ashtray with Solid Wood Base, Black
A Merbau wood base gives this OILP a grounded feel for a table where a lighter metal ashtray might shift. The polished zinc tray and central dome make it a more furniture-like choice than the all-metal Extra-Large Outdoor and Indoor Cigar Ashtray with Lid, though it gives up that model’s lid and deeper bowl for holding ash between cleanings. Four rests keep it useful for a shared session, and the smooth tray is easy to wipe. The square 5.91-inch footprint is fairly compact, but the listed weight of 0.79 kg and conflicting size and weight details make it harder to judge portability and exact fit. This pick suits a mostly stationary lounge table; buyers who regularly move their ashtray outdoors may prefer a lighter or more clearly specified option.
Pros:- Merbau wood base adds stability against incidental movement
- Four rests accommodate multiple cigars
- Polished metal tray is easy to wipe clean
- Suitable for indoor and outdoor use
Cons:- Product details give conflicting dimensions and weights
- Heavy construction is less convenient to carry
- No lid is listed to contain ash or shield the bowl
Best for: Cigar smokers furnishing a stable indoor lounge or covered patio table for several users
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a lightweight travel ashtray or reliable measurements before choosing a tight-fit spot
- Brand:OILP
- Materials:Merbau wood, zinc
- Color:Black
- Shape:Square
- Cigar rests:4
- Dimensions:5.91 x 5.91 x 1.42 in (listed)
- Item weight:0.79 kg (listed)
- Use:Indoor and outdoor
Our verdict“Pick this OILP for a steady shared tabletop display if portability and precise sizing are secondary.”
Roygra Metal Cigar Ashtray with Lid, 4 Cigar Holders
The Roygra’s compact, lidded design makes it a practical choice when a shared ashtray needs to occupy less table space. It has four cigar grooves like the larger Extra-Large Outdoor and Indoor Cigar Ashtray with Lid, but its 4.5-inch dimensions make it easier to place on a small table; the tradeoff is less room for ash. A central extinguishing platform gives cigars a designated resting and extinguishing spot, and the detachable design should make cleaning more manageable. The metal body and lid are described as guarding against wind and rain, but the details do not say whether it is dishwasher-safe or specify a cleaning method beyond detachment. Choose it for a compact group setup, while smokers who prioritize capacity should look to the larger OILP.
Pros:- Lid helps contain odors and shield ash from wind and rain
- Four grooves provide shared cigar rests in a compact footprint
- Central platform offers a dedicated extinguishing spot
- Detachable design eases access for cleaning
Cons:- Compact dimensions offer less ash capacity than the larger OILP lidded model
- Dishwasher safety and specific cleaning instructions are not provided
Best for: Small-patio or balcony users who want a lidded ashtray for a few cigar smokers
Not ideal for: Frequent hosts who need a deep bowl to hold substantial ash between cleanings
- Brand:Roygra
- Material:Metal
- Color:Bronze
- Shape:Taper
- Capacity:4 cigar holders
- Dimensions:4.5 x 3.7 x 4.5 in
- Weight:0.37 kg
- Model:CigarAshtrayWithLid-Bronze
- Features:Lid, central extinguishing platform, detachable design
Our verdict“Choose the Roygra when you want four cigar rests and a lid in a smaller footprint, and can empty it more often.”
Roygra Ceramic Cigar Ashtray, Single Holder
For one cigar at a time, this single-groove ceramic ashtray keeps the setup small and direct. At 4.8 by 2.8 inches, it is easier to carry or fit on a personal side table than the four-rest Roygra Metal Cigar Ashtray with Lid. That compact shape limits its job, though: it does not serve a group or offer a lid to contain ash outdoors. The padded base helps protect the surface below, while the ceramic body is described as heat-resistant, waterproof, and easy to clean. Those traits make it a straightforward personal option for indoor use or occasional outdoor placement, but its low profile and single capacity suit individual use better than a patio gathering. Choose the metal Roygra if several people need rests and a cover.
Pros:- Compact oval shape is easy to carry and place on small tables
- Single cigar groove keeps the format simple for personal use
- Padded base helps protect tabletop surfaces
- Ceramic body is described as heat-resistant, waterproof, and easy to clean
Cons:- Single-cigar capacity does not suit shared smoking
- No lid is listed to shield ash from wind or rain
- Small size provides less room for accumulated ash than group models
Best for: Solo cigar smokers who want a compact ashtray for a desk, side table, or occasional outdoor use
Not ideal for: Couples or groups who need multiple rests, greater ash capacity, or a lid against wind
- Brand:Roygra
- Material:Ceramic
- Color:Black
- Shape:Oval
- Dimensions:4.8 x 2.8 x 1 in
- Weight:5.29 oz
- Capacity:Single cigar
- Use:Indoor and outdoor
- Special feature:Cigar groove
Our verdict“Choose this Roygra for personal cigar use in a small footprint; pick a multi-rest model for shared sessions.”
How We Picked
I compared these 14 cigar ashtrays by how well their stated design serves common settings: a home smoking area, a shared table, or an outdoor spot. I gave weight to the number and shape of cigar rests, tray capacity, material, stability cues, ease of cleaning, and practical extras such as cutters, liners, or lids. A feature counted most when it solved a real use problem, rather than simply adding complexity.
The order favors versatile designs first, then models with a clear advantage for a narrower need. The GUEVARA porcelain tray ranks as the best general-purpose pick; the walnut BESUPERT earns a place for buyers who want integrated accessories; and silicone, lidded, compact, or single-rest models move up for their particular use cases. Product descriptions do not establish exact dimensions, weight, or weather resistance for every item, so I avoid treating those details as proven performance.
| cigar ashtray | Shape | Color | Brand |
|---|---|---|---|
| GUEVARA Large Porcelain Cigar | Round | Beige | — |
| Square Wooden Cigar Ashtray wi | Square | Brown | MDCGFOD |
| Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtrays | Square | Black | Roygra |
| GUEVARA 8-Inch Round Outdoor C | Round | Yellow | — |
| USEAMIE Large Silicone Cigar A | Square | Black | USEAMIE |
| BESUPERT Premium Walnut Wood C | Square | Brown | BESUPERT |
| Seliau Large Black Ceramic Cig | Square | Black | Seliau |
| Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtray | Square | Black | Roygra |
| OILP Square Metal Cigar Ashtra | Square | — | OILP |
| Roygra Silicone Cigar Ashtray | Square | Black | Roygra |
| Extra-Large Outdoor and Indoor | Round | Bronze | OILP |
| OILP Cigar Ashtray with Solid | Square | Black | OILP |
| Roygra Metal Cigar Ashtray wit | Taper | Bronze | Roygra |
| Roygra Ceramic Cigar Ashtray | Oval | Black | Roygra |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Cigar Ashtrays
Choosing among cigar ashtrays is easier when you start with the place the tray will live and how many people may use it. Material, footprint, rest layout, and cleanup can matter more day to day than appearance or accessory count. These broader checks can help you avoid a tray that looks right but does not suit your routine.
Match the Material to the Setting
Think about where the tray will sit before choosing its finish. Ceramic and porcelain provide a smooth surface that is generally easy to wipe, but they can chip or break if knocked onto a hard floor. Silicone is flexible and convenient to move, which can suit travel or casual outdoor use, though some buyers may prefer a firmer, more formal-looking tray on a lounge table. Metal can be durable, but its finish and shape affect how readily residue shows and how it should be cleaned. Wood adds warmth, yet ash and moisture can call for more attentive care. Check the maker’s cleaning guidance instead of assuming every material tolerates soaking or abrasive tools.
Choose Capacity for Your Usual Gathering
A tray with more rests can be useful when several people smoke together, but it takes up more table space and may be awkward for a solo smoker. Count how many cigars you expect to park at once, then leave room for ash to fall into the bowl without crowding the rests. A single-rest design can keep a small side table uncluttered, while a four-rest tray suits shared use. Do not assume a high rest count means a deep ash bowl; those are separate design features. If you host outdoors, consider where the tray will sit when it is not in use. A larger footprint is only helpful if the surface can accommodate it safely.
Treat Stability and Placement as Safety Questions
Placement affects whether a tray feels convenient and whether it is likely to be bumped. On a narrow armrest or crowded table, a wide base and a manageable shape can matter more than decorative details. Check the listed dimensions and weight when available, since product names such as “large” do not provide a consistent scale. Keep any ashtray away from table edges, fabrics, and surfaces that could be damaged by heat or falling ash. Outdoor wind can scatter loose ash from an open bowl, so a lid may help between uses, though it does not replace safe handling of a lit cigar. A heavy ceramic model may feel settled on a patio table but be less convenient to carry inside.
Think Through Cleanup Before You Buy
Routine cleaning often decides whether a tray remains pleasant to use. Smooth bowls tend to be simpler to wipe than designs with narrow corners, removable parts, or decorative grooves where residue can collect. A stainless-steel liner can separate the ash-catching surface from a wood exterior, but check whether the liner lifts out for cleaning. Silicone can be easier to handle and store, although lingering odors may matter to buyers who keep a tray indoors. For lidded models, consider how ash is emptied and whether the lid adds an extra surface to clean. Match the care instructions to the time you are willing to spend after each session.
Pay for Extras Only When You Will Use Them
Built-in cutters and accessory bundles can reduce the number of separate items on a table, but they do not make the ashtray itself better at collecting ash. If you already own a cutter you like, an integrated one may add bulk without solving a problem. A two-pack can make sense for placing trays in separate rooms or keeping a spare ready, while a single larger tray may be easier to keep track of. Lids have practical value when you need to contain ash between cleanups, but they add a part to store. Focus on the feature that removes friction from your routine, then judge the rest of the design on its own merits.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a lidded cigar ashtray a good choice for a patio?
It can be useful when you want to keep loose ash contained between sessions or limit exposure to breezes. A lid also adds a piece to remove, clean, and store, so it may be unnecessary if you empty the tray after each use. Check how the lid fits and how the tray is emptied before choosing one. Do not treat a lid as a substitute for extinguishing a cigar safely or for keeping hot ash away from combustible surfaces. For a patio, placement and a stable surface still matter.
Should I choose a four-rest ashtray if I usually smoke alone?
Only if you expect to use the extra rests or want room to set down more than one cigar. A four-rest layout can be helpful for guests, but it may occupy more table area than a single-rest design. The rest count does not tell you how much ash the bowl can hold, so check capacity and dimensions separately. If your smoking spot is compact, a simpler tray may be easier to place and clear. For shared use, extra rests can reduce crowding around one cigar rest.
Which material is easiest to maintain indoors?
Smooth ceramic or porcelain is often a practical indoor choice because its bowl can be wiped clean without special handling. Silicone is flexible and easy to move, though some people may prefer a rigid tray on a formal tabletop. Wood can look at home in a lounge, but it may need more care around ash and moisture, particularly if the ash-catching surface is not removable. Metal care depends on its finish and construction. Follow the product’s cleaning instructions and avoid assuming that any material is safe for abrasive cleaners or soaking.
Does a built-in cutter make an ashtray set a better buy?
A built-in cutter makes sense if you want fewer separate accessories on your table and expect to use that cutter. It adds less value if you already have a preferred cutter or want the simplest possible tray. Consider whether the cutter can be cleaned or replaced independently and whether its placement makes the tray awkward to handle. An accessory does not compensate for a bowl that is too small or a base that does not suit your table. Compare the core ashtray design first, then treat extras as a convenience.
What should I check before using a cigar ashtray outside?
Check the dimensions, material care guidance, and whether the design has a lid or another way to limit scattered ash. Product labels that mention outdoor use do not automatically establish resistance to rain, sun, or temperature changes. A ceramic tray can be convenient to wipe but may be vulnerable to impact, while a lighter design may move more easily in wind. Put the tray on a steady, heat-safe surface away from the edge. Bring it inside when not in use if the maker does not state that it can stay outdoors.
Conclusion
My best overall recommendation is the GUEVARA Large Porcelain Cigar Ashtray for buyers who want a straightforward ceramic option for regular use. For best value in flexibility, the Roygra silicone two-pack suits people who want trays in separate spots; for a more accessory-rich premium-style pick, BESUPERT pairs a walnut base with four rests and a cutter. Beginners may prefer a simple, easy-to-clean bowl such as the GUEVARA porcelain model rather than paying for extras they may not use. Choose the lidded extra-large model for a patio or shared area where containing loose ash matters, and consider a single-rest ceramic tray when table space is limited. The right cigar ashtray is the one whose material, size, and cleanup fit the place you actually smoke.
Fall yard work Picks
15-Foot Halloween Pumpkin Inflatable with LED Lights and Air Blower
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
